The most current OFA published statistics for Tibetan Spaniels, through Dec. 2010, are:
Registry (which tests performed) Rank of incidence in breeds Number of evaluations % Abnormal % Normal
Baer Hearing for congenital deafness N/A 2 0.0 100.00
Cardiac N/A 28 0.0 100.00
Elbow Dysplasia N/A 65 7.7 92.3
Hip Dysplasia 111 307 7.8 90.6
Patella Luxation 13 64 9.4 90.6
Thyroid N/A 12 8.3 83.3
As of the end of the 3rd Quarter in 2011, there were 593 entries in the OFA databases for Tibetan Spaniels. This total of 593 entries represent 320 actual dogs. Many of these 320 Tibbies were tested for 1 condition. Others were tested for 2 or more conditions. It is interesting to note that of these 320 Tibetan Spaniels, only 38 were eligible & received a CHIC number.
Statistics for the year ending Dec. 2011 will be posted here to keep this info as current as possible & for comparison to previous year.
I also find it interesting that other small Breeds, with similar conformation & origination as the Tibetan Spaniel, are being found to have many problems with hips. The Pug is currently 64.3% for hip dysplasia, Pugs also have a 53.3% incidence of elbow dysplasia & 6.8% for patellar luxation. . The Shih Tzu is at 19.4% for hip dysplasia & only 3.8% for elbows & 2.1% for patellar luxation.
Statistics for Tibetan Spaniels, through Dec. 2011 are:
Registry Rank of incidence in breeds Number of evaluations % Abnormal % Normal
Baer Hearing for congenital deafness N/A 2 0.0 100.00
Cardiac N/A 29 0.0 100.00
Elbow Dysplasia N/A 69 7.2 92.8
Hip Dysplasia 112 319 8.2 90.3
Patella Luxation 6 93 11.8 88.2
Thyroid N/A 12 8.3 83.3
PLEASE NOTE; ZEN TAO TIBETAN SPANIELS IS THE ONLY TIBETAN SPANIEL BREEDER WHO HAS SUBMITTED REPORTS FOR PATELLA LUXATION TO OFA FOR 4 TIBBIES WHO DID NOT CERTIFY & WHO ALLOWED PUBLICATION OF THOSE DOGS ON THE OFA WEBSITE & ALSO PUBLISHED THE RESULTS ON MY OWN WEBSITE. ONE OF THOSE DOGS, FU, DEFINITELY HAD NO PATELLAR LUXATION AT AGE 2 YEARS, AS CHECKED BY THE VET WHO DID HIS OFA HIP XRAYS & NOTED ON HIS RECORDS. HOWEVER, NO FORMAL APPLICATION WAS MADE AT THAT TIME OR 3 YEARS LATER WHEN THE SAME VET FOUND HIS STIFLES TO BE 2/0. BY THE TIME I WAS DOING THE OFA PATELLAR LUXATION EXAMS, 2 YEARS LATER, HIS EXAMS RESULTS WERE 2/1. I CAN’T EXPLAIN WHY. IF THERE WAS AN INJURY, HE SHOWED NO SIGNS OF IT. BUT I DO HAVE DOCUMENTATION OF THIS & FIND IT INTERESTING.
While it appears there is a problem with patellar luxation in Tibetan Spaniels, due to the statistics, this may be true or it may be misleading. Total submissions through Dec. 2010 were only 64 dogs. In the next full year, only 29 other applications were submitted. Of those 29, 16 were submitted by me - 12 on dogs with normal patellas that did certify & 4 were submitted that did not certify. These dogs classifications were: one at 0/1, one at 1/1, & two at 2/1. While I would prefer all my Tibbies to be normal at 0/0, please read the descriptions of the classifications below. A Grade 1 can be a judgement call, as the patella may only luxate at full extention & not EASILY - but it still can be manipulated to luxate. My examiner marks it as a Grade 1 if it can be forced to luxate. Only those that absolutely cannot be made to luxate are classified as Normal or 0. That is correct & going by the requirements for the classification. It may annoy me, but it will also help me in my breeding program.
If owners of Tibetan Spaniels who do not certify would publicly release their results, we would know what the classifications are of those dogs & be better able to determine if there is indeed a problem in the breed. Are the others Grade 3 or Grade 4? Are these other Tibbies who did not certify related? Or are they isolated instances of occurences in individual dogs who come from lines where most are normal? Is the abnormal classification affecting the quality of life of the Tibbie? I just had a 15 1/2 year old Tibbie examined & found to be 1/0. He can still outrun me! Without more information, it is difficult to fully make use of the statistical results.
OFA PATELLAR LUXATION CLASSIFICATION
A method of classifying the degree of luxation and bony deformity is useful for diagnosis, and can be applied to either medial or lateral luxations by reversing the medial-lateral directional references. The position of the patella can easily be palpated starting at the tibial tubercle and working proximal along the patellar ligament to the patella.
Grade 1
Manually the patella easily luxates at full extension of the stifle joint, but returns to the trochlea when released. No crepitation is apparent. The medial, or very occasionally, lateral deviation of the tibial crest (with lateral luxation of the patella) is only minimal, and there is very slight rotation of the tibia. Flexion and extension of the stifle is in a straight line with no abduction of the hock.
Grade 2
There is frequent patellar luxation, which, in some cases, becomes more or less permanent. The limb is sometimes carried, although weight bearing routinely occurs with the stifle remaining slightly flexed. Especially under anesthesia it is often possible to reduce the luxation by manually turning the tibia laterally, but the patella reluxates with ease when manual tension of the joint is released. As much as 30 degrees of medial tibial torsion and a slight medial deviation of the tibial crest may exist. When the patella is resting medially the hock is slightly abducted. If the condition is bilateral, more weight is thrown onto the forelimbs.
Many dogs with this grade live with the condition reasonably well for many years, but the constant luxation of the patella over the medial trochlear ridge of the trochlea causes erosion of the articulating surface of the patella and also the proximal area of the medial lip. This results in crepitation becoming apparent when the patella is luxated manually.
Grade 3
The patella is permanently luxated with torsion of the tibia and deviation of the tibial crest of between 30 degrees and 50 degrees from the cranial/caudal plane. Although the luxation is not intermittent, many animals use the limb with the stifle held in a semi flexed position. The trochlea is very shallow or even flattened.
Grade 4
The tibia is medially twisted and the tibial crest may show further deviation medially with the result that it lies 50 degrees to 90 degrees from the cranial/caudal plane. The patella is permanently luxated. The patella lies just above the medial condyle and a space can be palpated between the patellar ligament and the distal end of the femur. The trochlea is absent or even convex. The limb is carried, or the animal moves in a crouched position, with the limb flexed.
*NOTE: Patellar luxation classifications may be published as 0/0, (meaning no luxation in right or left patella), or, for example, 0/2, (no luxation in left patella, grade 2 in right patella), etc. This method of publishing results is used more often in European Countries. You may see this in Health Registries or on websites in reference to individual dogs. I have this method also, in the descriptions of each of my individual dogs who have had the veterinarian exam & OFA application for patellar luxation completed by that veterinarian.
Zen Tao began submitting X-rays for OFA hip certification in 2001 on all foundation dogs. Examinations for the patellar luxation began in 2006.
While breeding & showing Cocker Spaniels from 1976 to 2002, Marianne Minks had yearly eye exams on all Cockers aged 2 years to after 8 years old, at which time those dogs became eligible for Permanent Certification through The American Spaniel Club Health Registry. OFA hip X-rays & evaluations began in the mid 1980s. Blood testing was also done on all foundation dogs for VWD & Factor 10 blood clotting deficiencies that are hereditary in the Cocker Spaniel Breed. We invite you to go online to The American Spaniel Club website & look for the Minks Cocker Spaniels in the Permanent Health Registry. Minks Cocker Spaniels are also published on the OFA website for hip certifications, as are Zen Tao Tibetan Spaniels. Please enjoy these websites. It is so wonderful to have such information readily available.